Building Relationships and Driving Conversions
In the digital age, onboarding emails are one of the most powerful tools a business can use to establish relationships with new subscribers and guide them through their customer journey. These emails provide a structured introduction to your brand while laying the foundation for trust, engagement, and conversions.
At Shiver Media, we’ve seen firsthand how a well-thought-out onboarding strategy can make or break the first impression. By welcoming new subscribers with tailored messaging and clear value, businesses can transform curious prospects into loyal customers. Let’s dive deeper into what makes a stellar onboarding email sequence, along with examples from projects we’ve crafted for clients across industries.
Why Onboarding Emails Matter
Before we jump into best practices, it’s worth emphasizing why onboarding emails are so impactful. These emails serve as the first touchpoint after a subscriber opts into your list. Beyond welcoming them, they also:
- Confirm interest through a double opt-in process.
- Set expectations about future communications.
- Establish credibility and authority.
- Nurture leads toward purchasing decisions.
The double opt-in is particularly crucial. It ensures your subscribers are genuinely interested and helps keep your email list clean, protecting your domain’s reputation and improving deliverability rates. Your first email should include a warm welcome and a request for confirmation. Once confirmed, you can start engaging with meaningful, targeted content.
When consulting or coaching, we emphasize balancing authenticity with strategic goals, a formula that’s worked across industries like e-commerce, coaching, and hospitality. By segmenting audiences and tailoring the messaging, our clients have seen substantial growth in both engagement and revenue.
1. The Welcome Sequence: Setting the Stage for Success
The first email your subscribers receive is the gateway to their journey with your brand. A well-designed Welcome Sequence ensures that their first impression is impactful, informative, and engaging.
Why It Matters
Your subscribers are at their most interested and curious right after signing up. The Welcome Sequence capitalizes on this moment by introducing your brand, highlighting the benefits of staying connected, and setting expectations for future emails.
Crafting an Effective Welcome Sequence
- Double Opt-In Confirmation: Ensure compliance with regulations like GDPR, CASL and CAN SPAM while filtering out invalid or uninterested subscribers. A double opt-in email confirms their subscription and adds an additional layer of trust.
- Warm Introduction: The first email should welcome them warmly, thank them for subscribing, and provide a glimpse into what they can expect from your content or services.
- Showcase Your Brand’s Value: Highlight your unique selling points. Whether it’s a free resource, an exclusive offer, or a link to valuable content, make it clear why they’ve made the right choice in subscribing.
- Encourage Interaction: Include links to your most popular blog posts, social channels, or tutorials, encouraging them to explore and engage further.
Real-Life Example: ShiverMedia’s Approach
We’ve created Welcome Sequences for numerous clients, tailoring each to their audience. For one client, we started with a friendly “Thanks for Joining!” email, which included a special discount code, followed by a second email introducing the brand’s story and values. The result? A 40% increase in first-week engagement.
1. Start with a Clear Strategy
The foundation of any successful onboarding series is a well-defined strategy. These emails should be more than just a polite hello—they should introduce your brand, build trust, and move subscribers closer to taking action.
Key Elements of a Welcome Strategy
- Set the Tone: Ensure your brand voice shines through. Whether it’s playful, professional, or heartfelt, your tone sets the stage for future interactions.
- Build Momentum: Keep subscribers engaged with a logical progression from one email to the next.
- Drive Action: Every email should have a clear call to action (CTA), whether that’s to explore your website, download a guide, or make a purchase.
Pro Tip: A strong first email introduces your brand’s story, encourages interaction, and creates excitement. The first email should spark curiosity—it’s the handshake that begins the relationship.
2. Confirm Interest and Deliver Value
How to Deliver Value
- Educational Content: Share a guide or tutorial relevant to your audience.
- Promotional Offers: Provide a discount code or a free trial to encourage purchases.
- Supportive Resources: Link to FAQs or how-to videos.
For example, one of our clients in the hospitality industry saw a 25% boost in bookings after incorporating personalized travel tips and local guides into their onboarding emails.
3. Tell Your Story
Storytelling is an underrated yet powerful tool in onboarding emails. It’s an opportunity to showcase your authenticity and connect with your audience on a deeper level.
Crafting a Story Sequence
Our approach to storytelling often involves a “low point to breakthrough” narrative:
- The Challenge: Share a relatable struggle that resonates with your audience.
- The Epiphany: Highlight the turning point that led to your brand’s creation or success.
- The Resolution: Demonstrate how you or your products/services solved the problem.
One standout example is a coaching client we worked with who shared their journey from burnout to balance. The story resonated with subscribers, leading to a 35% increase in course sign-ups.
Pro Tip: End your story sequence with a cliffhanger, inviting subscribers to look out for the next email. For instance, tease an exclusive offer or resource they won’t want to miss.
4. Introduce the First Purchase Offer
Timing is everything when it comes to introducing your first pitch. After nurturing your subscriber through the first few emails, it’s time to present an offer they can’t refuse.
How to Make the Pitch
- Soft Approach: Frame the offer as a thank-you for joining your community.
- Hard Approach: Use urgency and scarcity, such as “Limited-time offer—expires in 48 hours!”
- Social Proof: Incorporate testimonials or reviews to build trust.
In our experience, the sweet spot for introducing a first purchase offer is email 3 or 4. For example, a fashion brand client used a “Welcome Discount” campaign to convert 40% of new subscribers into customers within the first week.
Pro Tip: Follow up purchase emails with tracking information and a thank-you note to reinforce trust and encourage repeat purchases.
5. Create an Engaging Design
Design is often overlooked but plays a critical role in how onboarding emails are perceived. Clean, professional design enhances readability and encourages action.
Design Best Practices
- Mobile Optimization: Ensure your emails are responsive and look great on all devices.
- Strong CTAs: Use buttons instead of text links for better visibility and click-through rates.
- Visual Hierarchy: Make important elements like headlines and CTAs stand out.
We consistently emphasize the value of storytelling in onboarding emails. For example, a food blogger crafted a story-driven campaign about her journey discovering unique spices during her travels. Each email featured vibrant images of the spices paired with engaging text about their origins and uses. This captivating sequence resonated with her audience, leading to a 60% increase in lead generation conversions compared to her previous, less narrative-driven
Bonus Sequences: Going Beyond the Basics
Once your onboarding series is up and running, consider adding specialized sequences to deepen relationships and re-engage inactive subscribers.
Storytelling Sequence
Our storytelling sequences often explore the journey of building a brand, from struggles to triumphs. These emails:
- Build emotional connections with subscribers.
- Highlight the values and mission behind your brand.
- Encourage readers to see your brand as more than a product or service provider.
Re-Engagement Sequence
Target subscribers who haven’t opened your emails or made a purchase in a while. Offer them a compelling reason to come back, such as:
- Exclusive discounts.
- Personalized product recommendations.
- Engaging content, like a popular blog post or webinar replay.
Real-World Results from Shiver Media
Over the years, we’ve fine-tuned onboarding strategies for clients across industries. A few standout successes include:
- E-Commerce Client: A playful welcome series with humor and GIFs led to a 45% open rate and a 20% conversion rate.
- Coaching Business: A deeply personal story sequence built trust and resulted in a 30% increase in course sign-ups.
- Travel Agency: Offering free destination guides in the first email boosted engagement rates by 60%.
Final Thoughts
Onboarding emails are your chance to make a lasting first impression and nurture subscribers into loyal customers. By implementing these five best practices—starting with a clear strategy, confirming interest, delivering value, telling your story, introducing an offer, and focusing on design—you can create a sequence that stands out in today’s crowded inboxes.
Athoughtful and authentic approach to onboarding can deliver remarkable results. Whether you’re a coach, e-commerce retailer, or travel agency, investing time in crafting a meaningful onboarding sequence is a surefire way to build connections and drive conversions.
Now, it’s your turn. Start refining your onboarding strategy today, and watch your email marketing efforts transform.
OR Reach out and we can get your sequences locked in for you in a short time. Watch the leads generate revenue quickly.